18  –  River  and  wetland  health  in  the  Lake  Eyre  Basin  –  an  economic  perspective  161  Lake  Eyre  Basin  rivers,  though  neither  of  these  valuation  exercises  has  previously  been  done.  Contrastingly,  it  is  only  possible  to  identify  a  change  in  non-use  value.  Thus  economists  calculate  the  total  use  but  their  estimate  of  non-use  value  focuses  on  how  value  changes  with  a  new  resource  use  option.  Economists  cannot  calculate  the  total  use  and  non-use  value  of  a  wetland  or  river.  Measuring  the  economic  value  of  the  environment  How  does  an  economist  estimate  the  economic  values  of  the  wetlands  and  rivers  of  the  Lake  Eyre  Basin?  There  are  three  broad  sets  of  approaches.  First,  market-based  techniques  can  be  used  to  estimate  economic  values  for  direct  and  indirect  uses  of  the  environment.  This  includes  the  productivity  approach,  which  estimates  change  in  economic  value.  For  example,  it  would  be  possible  to  measure  the  loss  of  economic  value  of  flooding  for  grazing  in  the  Channel  Country  of  the  Lake  Eyre  Basin,  if  irrigation  diverted  water  from  the  Thomson  River  upstream.  Further,  in  the  group  of  market-based  techniques,  replacement  or  damage  costs  can  be  used  to  estimate  values  where  there  is  a  loss  of  an  ecosystem  service  and  there  is  a  need  to  develop  an  alternative  to  replace  the  service.  For  example,  destruction  or  degradation  of  a  wetland  may  remove  its  ecosystem  service  of  purifying  water  or  tourist  value,  requiring  a  replacement  water  source.  This  may  require  establishing  a  new  water  treatment  plant  or  treating  water  to  a  higher  level  of  quality  where  the  cost  of  replacement  indicates  the  value  of  the  resource.  This  approach  could  be  used  in  the  context  of  rehabilitating  the  pollution  effects  of  the  Lady  Annie  Mine  (see  Chapter  19).  Another  example  is  the  reductions  in  flows  to  the  lower  River  Murray,  which  required  governments  to  spend  more  than  $2.4  billion,  including  a  desalination  plant  for  Adelaide  that  was  highly  reliant  on  the  River  Murray  for  its  water  supply  (Kingsford  et  al.  2011).  The  second  set  of  approaches  is  the  revealed  preference  techniques.  These  use  information  from  related  markets  to  estimate  values.  One  commonly  used  technique  is  the  travel  cost  approach  for  estimating  recreational  use  values.  For  example,  we  can  tell  something  about  the  recreation  value  people  have  for  a  destination  such  as  a  wetland  by  how  much  they  would  spend  in  getting  to  their  location  in  terms  of  travel  cost  and  time.  People  are  clearly  prepared  to  spend  a  lot  of  money  visiting  Lake  Eyre  (see  Chapter  13).  We  know  that  as  the  cost  goes  up,  people  tend  to  visit  less  often  and  consequently  it  would  be  expected  that  there  may  be  proportionally  less  visitation  for  people  further  away.  This  relationship  allows  estimation  of  a  demand  curve  for  identifying  recreation  value.  A  second  revealed  preference  technique  is  hedonic  pricing,  which  involves  using  property  prices  to  identify  environmental  values.  An  expectation  is  that  house  prices  change  with  environmental  quality  this  technique  separates  the  change  in  economic  value  due  to  changes  in  environmental  quality  from  the  characteristics  of  the  house  or  community.  This  informs  about  the  amenity  value  of  the  local  environment.  For  example,  if  there  were  a  decline  in  the  vegetation  of  the  Channel  Country  along  the  Diamantina  River,  this  might  affect  property  values.  Finally,  there  are  stated  preference  techniques,  with  contingent  valuation  and  choice  modelling,  the  two  most  widely  used.  Contingent  valuation  involves  estimating  non-market  values  through  directly  questioning  respondents  about  their  willingness  to  pay  for  specific  
Downloaded from CSIRO with access from at 216.73.216.187 on Oct 31, 2025, 10:44 PM. (c) CSIRO Publishing
 
            















































































































































































































































































