Lake  Eyre  Basin  Rivers  236  and  Kingsford  2011).  There  also  needs  to  be  adequate  assessment  of  the  costs  and  benefits  to  economic  environmental  values  of  the  Lake  Eyre  Basin,  relative  to  the  benefits  of  development  (see  Chapter  18).  This  includes  direct  costs  to  less  ephemeral,  stable  industries,  such  as  livestock  grazing  and  tourism.  Socio-economic  analyses  should  also  expose  the  largely  invisible  subsidies  that  underpin  many  large  irrigation  developments  and  extend  over  decades,  as  well  as  incorporate  the  long-term  costs  of  rehabilitation.  Inevitably,  this  discussion  sidesteps  the  consequences  of  ‘sleeper’  licence  activation  and  the  development  of  unallocated  water  in  the  Cooper  Creek  and  Georgina–Diamantina  catchments.  Although  there  are  considerable  financial  impediments  to  development  (e.g.  costs  of  infrastructure  development,  limitations  of  water  access,  proximity  to  markets  and  transport  costs),  the  possibility  remains  that  these  licences  may  one  day  become  activated  when  economic  conditions  are  favourable.  If  the  maxim  for  human  health  that  ‘prevention  is  better  than  the  cure’  is  equally  applicable  to  the  environment,  there  remains  a  good  case  to  resume  the  sleeper  licences  and  remove  unallocated  water  from  the  Queensland  water  plans  in  the  Lake  Eyre  Basin,  recognising  and  protecting  its  outstanding  values.  This  would  require  compensation  for  irrigation  licences,  provided  either  by  governments  to  current  users,  or  through  the  purchase  of  licences  by  a  third  party  (e.g.  a  non-government  organisation),  coupled  with  agreements  that  would  prevent  future  development  of  the  river  basin.  One  criticism  of  this  approach  is  that  ‘closing-off’  such  a  river  basin  to  water  resource  development  abrogates  our  local,  regional  and  global  responsibility  to  provide  for  the  food  and  fibre  needs  of  the  world.  It  is  time  that  governments  focus  more  on  the  demand  side  of  the  equation  for  food  and  fibre  and  improve  the  efficiency  of  existing  water  developments  and  systems  in  order  to  increase  production.  This  includes  the  potential  for  urban  centres,  consumers  of  most  food  and  fibre,  to  also  engage  in  agricultural  production  within  their  footprint  (Barthel  and  Isendahl  2013).  Critically,  the  current  policy  instruments  preventing  construction  of  large  off-river  storages,  increases  in  pump  size  or  volume  on  floodplains  are  the  most  important  barrier  to  rapid  large  scale  development  of  irrigation  and  must  remain  in  place.  Of  the  other  threats  to  the  sustainability  of  the  rivers  of  the  Lake  Eyre  Basin,  climate  change  is  potentially  the  most  significant,  although  current  understanding  of  the  effects  will  depend  on  knowledge  of  changes  to  rainfall  patterns  and  temperature.  Temperature  is  increasing  (Reisinger  et  al.  2014),  which  will  mean  increasing  evaporation,  partly  offset  by  increasing  rainfall  (Greenville  et  al.  2012).  Communities  and  governments  should  continue  to  develop  policies  that  limit  greenhouse  gas  emissions  and  stabilise  temperatures.  At  a  local  scale,  there  may  be  a  need  for  active  policies  to  enhance  the  persistence  of  key  refuge  waterholes,  with  significant  biodiversity  value.  Solutions  to  avoid  pollution  disasters,  such  as  spillage  from  Lady  Annie  copper  mine  (see  Chapter  19),  must  involve  rigorous  assessment  of  the  proximity  of  such  mines  to  rivers  and  the  risk  of  pollution.  Further,  if  development  proceeds,  a  realistic  bond  which  adequately  provides  for  restoration,  must  be  negotiated.  Ubiquitous  plant  and  animal  invaders  continue  to  wreak  damage  to  industries  and  the  ecosystems.  Although  there  is  generally  a  strong  commitment  to  mitigating  their  impacts,  levels  of  accountability  and  measurements  of  success  or  failure  are  often  inadequate.  Systems  of  strategic  adaptive  management  can  provide  a  more  transparent  and  rigorous  framework  
Downloaded from CSIRO with access from at 216.73.216.214 on Oct 31, 2025, 5:34 AM. (c) CSIRO Publishing
 
            















































































































































































































































































